Father’s Day arrives each June like clockwork. Cards, advertisements, neckties, hats, and mugs about dads seem to be everywhere we look. But what happens when a clock stopped over seven years ago—when the children who once colored cards for their dad suddenly lost the chance to hand them over?
For those of us who still grieve what was lost, Father’s Day became something to avoid, a Hallmark holiday we pretend doesn’t exist.
That was our reality. We spent each June honoring my dad and other great dads in our kids’ lives. And at the same time, we avoided the commercials, steered clear of church photo booths, and spent the second Sunday in June far from people celebrating something my kids had lost.
Yet this year felt different.
God has woven a new chapter: a wise and gentle “bonus dad” has stepped into our story. The kids want to celebrate with him, to shout their gratitude. They have spent weeks asking when Father’s Day is and what they can make and do to celebrate him.
And yet, I found myself unsure of how to proceed.
We’ve avoided this day for so long, and amid the happy tears, a little sadness still lingers. Sitting at the same table are their bonus dad’s children, carrying their own memories and loyalties. Joy and tenderness now share the same plate, and everyone walks softly.
So in these past few weeks, I’ve wrestled with how to honor both grief and gratitude in a blended family on Father’s Day. I asked for advice. I turned to Scripture. Here’s what I realized:
- God Draws Near to Broken Hearts
Grief does not have an expiration date. Psalm 34:18 says, “The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.” Our heavenly Father acknowledges loss without rushing us past it. We can still honor and remember Ben even amid thanking God for the gift of Max.
- Scripture Tells Us About Fathers Who Stand in as Earthly Fathers
The Bible presents God as a Father who welcomes, adopts, and accepts us into His family (Romans 8:15). In Matthew 1, we see Joseph step into the role of earthly father for Jesus, raising and protecting Him with love and courage. A bonus dad’s role isn’t second place—it reflects God’s adoptive embrace. That is something to recognize and deeply appreciate.
(Bonus fact: Did you know Max’s first name is actually Joseph? How cool is that?)
- We Rejoice and Weep—Sometimes in the Same Breath
Blended families carry mixed emotions. One child may be bursting with excitement to bake muffins for a bonus dad, while another feels unsure of how to proceed. Biological children may wrestle with the idea of others sharing a day that once belonged solely to their father.
“Rejoice with those who rejoice; weep with those who weep” (Romans 12:15). There’s room for both. Yesterday we rejoiced—and deep down, I believe Ben is rejoicing too, watching the love being poured into his children. That thought warms my heart even as it aches. I am so deeply grateful they get to feel a father’s love again.
Blended families navigating different kinds of loss rarely look the same. Trusting God means acknowledging that we don’t need a perfect template. We place the fragile, beautiful mix of grief and gratitude in His hands.
This Father’s Day, I tread lightly.
We celebrated my amazing dad, who has shown up for me and my kids in countless ways. We remembered Ben, who prayed for and gave life to each of our children—and loved them more than anything in the world. And we celebrated Max, an incredible man who has stepped in with compassion, strength, and love.
Our family looks different now. And I’m learning that’s okay.
Mourning and dancing can intertwine, and we can rejoice as we press forward.
Happy Father’s Day, Dad.
Happy Father’s Day in heaven, Ben.
Happy Father’s Day here on earth, Max.
You are all so deeply loved and appreciated.




